top of page

Mentoring Program Audit Checklist

Score your mentoring program and find what to fix next .For HR and talent teams running mentoring at scale who want a scored view of what is working and what needs fixing.

Mentoring Program Audit Checklist

What is the Mentoring Program Audit Checklist?

The Mentoring Program Audit Checklist is a free self-assessment from Teleskope for HR and talent teams who run mentoring programs. It scores a program on 20 statements across strategy, matching, engagement, and measurement, totals the result out of 100, and places it in one of four levels with guidance on what to improve next.

​

  • Score your mentoring program on 20 statements across strategy, matching, engagement, and measurement.

  • Pinpoint the weakest of the four areas from your section totals.

  • Prioritize next steps with a four-level scoring guide, from At Risk to Optimized.

Get the free checklist

What is inside the Mentoring Program Audit Checklist?

Many mentoring programs start well and then stall. Matches fade after the first meeting, leaders approve the program but never champion it, and no one can say what success looks like or whether the program reached it.

A structured audit makes those gaps visible. Each statement is scored from 1 (strongly disagree) to 5 (strongly agree), so you can compare sections, retake the audit after changes, and show progress over time.

Program strategy and design

Five statements on business goals, mentoring formats, a program charter, structured phases, and executive sponsorship. Use it to check that the program is built around outcomes, not only good intentions.

Matching logic and participant fit

Five statements on matching criteria, participant preferences, auditable matching, program-specific rules, and rematching. Use it to see whether pairs are set up to succeed from the first meeting.

Engagement and enablement

Five statements on onboarding, nudges and reminders, engagement monitoring, defined roles, and recognizing success. Use it to find where participants drop off and what support is missing.

Measurement and growth readiness

Five statements on KPIs, success definitions, feedback loops, stakeholder reporting, and tools that support scale. Use it to test whether you can prove impact and grow the program across regions.

Scoring summary

Section totals out of 25, an overall score out of 100, and four status levels with what each means. Use it to turn your score into a short list of priorities.

What to do with your score

Pointers to the next topics to explore, from choosing formats to proving ROI. Use it to plan your next round of improvements.

Who is the Mentoring Program Audit Checklist for?

  • HR and talent leaders responsible for one or more mentoring programs

  • Mentoring program managers preparing a mid-year or annual program review

  • L&D teams expanding mentoring across regions, departments, or business units

  • Executive sponsors who want a quick, structured read on program health

  • Teams deciding whether their current tools can support mentoring at scale

Frequently asked questions about mentoring program audits

How do you audit a mentoring program?

 

Score your program against a consistent set of statements, grouped by area, rather than relying on attendance alone. The checklist covers strategy, matching, engagement, and measurement, with five statements each scored from 1 to 5. Add the section totals for a score out of 100, then use the four status levels to decide what to fix first.

How should mentors and mentees be matched?

 

Match on layered criteria such as skills, goals, job level, department, region, and language, and let participants state preferences like skill focus, format, and availability. Use different matching rules for different programs, such as leadership versus onboarding, and keep the process automated and auditable. Always give participants a way to share feedback or request a rematch.

How do you measure the success of a mentoring program?

 

Start by defining what success means for each program you run, such as retention or promotion goals. Then track participation rate, match success, engagement frequency, and completion, and collect feedback at more than one point in the program. The checklist scores measurement and growth readiness as its own section, so you can see where reporting falls short.

Related Resources

Mentoring playbook

The Enterprise Mentoring Playbook

How modern mentoring programs work, with real-world examples

Employee Events Guide

A Guide to Running Employee Events at Scale

Processes, approvals, and reporting for enterprise employee events

bottom of page